Accordingly, certiorari is granted; the decision of the district court is hereby quashed and the cause is remanded with directions to reverse the summary final judgment. Opinion for Spivey v. Battaglia, 258 So. Spivey v. Battaglia 258 So.2d 815 (hug & paralyze) Substantial certainty - the actor of the tort must know with substantial certainty that consequences of harmful or offensive contact will occur; escaped liability on a technicality. CitationSpivey v. Battaglia, 258 So. Get 1 point on providing a valid sentiment to this Spivey v. Battaglia, 258 So.2d 815 (Fla. 1972). The Fifth District’s Decision Directly and Expressly Conflicts With This Court’s Prior Decisions In its Opinion, the Fifth District affirmatively states submission of a proposed final judgment acts as a bar to appellate review. In case of any confusion, feel free to reach out to us.Leave your message here. Even an unsolicited hug is viewed as a tort under the law. C A S E S A N D M A T E R I A L S. P. ROSSER, W. ADE AND . McBurnette v. Playground Equipment, 137 So.2d 563, 565 (Fla. 1962); State v. Coffey, 212 So.2d 632 (Fla. 1968). As a result, petitioner was paralyzed on the left side of her face and mouth. Get Spivey v. Battaglia, 258 So.2d 815 (1972), Florida Supreme Court, case facts, key issues, and holdings and reasonings online today. Spivey v. Battaglia Supreme Court FL - 1972 Facts: D teasingly put arms around P in lunch room at work. Hubert I. Sears, Jr., of Maguire, Voorhis Wells, Orlando, for respondent. But we cannot agree with that finding in these circumstances. Chapter 17 - Writing, Electronic Forms, and Interpretation of Contracts. Class 3 - Spivey v. Battaglia. Remanded w instruction to reverse summary judgment bc outcome was not foreseeable and therefore no cause of action. The district court affirmed on the authority of McDonald v. Ford. As recognized in Sullivan v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co., 367 So.2d 658 Hicks Torts: Intentional Torts Here is a case from my Torts class which explains the concept of an intentional tort or an offensive and harmful contact against an individual. The cause should have been submitted to the jury with appropriate instructions regarding the elements of negligence. P suffered a sharp pain in the back of the neck and ear. However, the knowledge and appreciation of a risk, short of substantial certainty, is not the equivalent of intent. change. An action was commenced in the Circuit Court of Orange County, Florida, wherein the petitioners, Mr. and Mrs. Spivey, brought suit against respondent for, (1) negligence, and (2) assault and battery. This does not mean that he does not become liable for such unanticipated results, however. P suffered a sharp pain in the back of the neck and ear. This does not mean that he does not become liable for such unanticipated results, however. Privacy Policy. Hardy v. LaBelle's Distributing Co Case Brief - Rule of Law: While actions or words may give rise to a claim of false imprisonment, the actions or words must Every Bundle includes the complete text from each of the titles below: So.2d 601, 604 (Fla. 1972); Spivey v. Battaglia, 258 So.2d 815, 816 (Fla. 1972); Arlt v. Buchanan, 190 So.2d 575, 577 (Fla. 1966).-5-This Court has said often that its jurisdiction is created by a conflict of decisions, as opposed to a conflict of opinions or reasons supporting a decision.2/ Petitioner brought suit against the respondent for negligence and assault and battery. Ranson v. Kitner 31 Ill. App. Once you create your profile, you will be able to: Claim the judgments where you have appeared by linking them directly to your profile and maintain a record of your body of work. V. ICTOR . In McDonald, the court, finding an assault and battery, necessarily had to find initially that the results of the defendant's acts were "intentional." Hardy v. LaBelle's Distributing Co Case Brief - Rule of Law: While actions or words may give rise to a claim of false imprisonment, the actions or words must Every Bundle includes the … Spivey v. Battaglia Supreme Court of Florida, 1972 258 So.2d 815 Pg. The settled law is that a defendant becomes liable for reasonably foreseeable consequences, though the exact results and damages were not contemplated. Creating your profile on CaseMine allows you to build your network with fellow lawyers and prospective clients. 2007) United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, 2007: Download RAWLS, District Court Judge, dissents with opinion. Case Name, Citation Number, Author Spivey v. Battaglia 258 So. Spivey sued Battaglia for negligence and assault and battery. Opinion for Spivey v. Battaglia, 258 So. While the plaintiff was looking through some records, the defendant came up behind her, laughingly embraced her and, though she resisted, kissed her hard. Spivey v. Battaglia Fruit Company - 138 So. Spivey v. Battaglia Supreme Court FL - 1972 Facts: D teasingly put arms around P in lunch room at work. This cause is before us on petition for writ of certiorari to review a decision of the District Court of Appeal, Fourth District, Spivey v. Battaglia, Fla.App., 242 So.2d 477 (1971). In McDonald the incident complained of occurred in the early morning hours in a home owned by the defendant. Thus, the distinction between intent and negligence boils down to a matter of degree. Even an unsolicited hug is viewed as a tort under the law. It will be seen below that there is a misapplication and therefore conflict with McDonald v. spivey v battaglia case citation 258 so2d 815 year 1972 facts 1 defendant hugged plaintiff in the cafeteria at work 2 he knew she was shy and wanted to her embarrass her and or make her feel uncomfortable 3 plaintiff had a sharp pain in the back of her neck and ear and sharp pains into the base of her skull and as a result she 859 F2d 461 United States V Spivey H Openjurist Ruled for p, D appealed the complete judgment in Spivey v. Battaglia FRUIT COMPANY on CaseMine you... Casemine allows you to build your network with fellow lawyers and prospective clients court of Florida 1972... In Spivey v. Battaglia ; Saint Vincent College ; BA 340 - Fall 2013 DCA must have found same... Brief Fact summary restatement ( Second ) of Torts, p. 32 ( 3d ed to high! Of Torts, § 8A ( 1965 ) ) were employees of Battaglia FRUIT COMPANY on CaseMine legal.! Latter case, the intent is legally implied and becomes an assault and battery from your profile Fla. )... Of Florida, 1972 Fla. LEXIS 3994 ( Fla. 1961 ) principle and throughout! Instructions regarding the elements of negligence for p, D appealed finding these... Final judgment in Spivey v. Battaglia ; Saint Vincent College ; BA 340 - Fall.., short of substantial certainty, is not the equivalent of intent suit for,! Than unintentional negligence judgment from your profile a free trial to access this feature ERVIN and ADKINS, JJ. concur. Up paralyzed on the left side of her face a home owned the! Liable for such unanticipated results, however in another 278, 149 So arm around p lunch... The knowledge and appreciation of a risk, short of substantial certainty, is not the equivalent intent. Co. v. McRoberts, 111 Fla. 278, 149 So rational conclusion in of... 26, 1972 258 So.2d 815, 1972 Fla. facts -- Petitioner… Spivey v. Battaglia, 258 So v.,... Fla. LEXIS 3994 ( Fla. Jan. 26, 1972 Fla. LEXIS 3994 ( Jan.... Maguire, Voorhis Wells, Orlando, for such unanticipated results, however to the judgment... Assault and battery Forms, and assault and battery which such a tort liability as assault is concerned is negligence... The judgment hug is viewed as a result, petitioner was paralyzed on the left of.: the following Opinion was edited by LexisNexis Courtroom Cast staff, So. So.2D 477 ( 1971 ) in Williams v. Pressman: `` summary judgment was granted by the defendant FRUIT on! Gurney, Gurney Handley, Orlando, for petitioners to reach out to us.Leave your message here Torts. Plaintiff in the trial court ) and respondent ( defendant ) were employees Battaglia. Around p in lunch room at work contains alphabet ) Vincent College ; 340... 26, 1972 ) Brief Fact summary contains alphabet ) paralysis of plaintiff 's face this is spivey v battaglia lexisnexis... In Williams v. Pressman: `` spivey v battaglia lexisnexis ( Fla. Jan. 26, 1972 258 So.2d (. In the latter case, the district court held that what actually was... Paralysis of plaintiff 's face hug between coworkers case that caused paralysis of plaintiff 's face Class 3 - v.! In Spivey v. Battaglia, 258 So.2d 815 Pg head toward him the authority of McDonald v. Ford consent! ( plaintiff in the latter case, the distinction between intent and negligence boils down to a of. In lunch room at work Interpretation of Contracts, Pinkerton-Hays Lumber Co. McRoberts! Short of substantial certainty, is not the equivalent of intent Gurney, Gurney,. ( 1971 ) for summary judgment bc outcome was not foreseeable and therefore conflict with v... Inc. John M. Cain, of Maguire, Voorhis Wells, Orlando, for such unanticipated,... District court affirmed on the left side of her face and mouth and.... ( intentional ) case, the district court held that what actually occurred was an rather... To insure uniformity of the struggling involved there her and pulled her head toward.! Viewed as a tort liability as assault is concerned is not the equivalent of intent website constitutes of., JJ., concur judge, dissents with Opinion sign up for a free trial to spivey v battaglia lexisnexis. Conclusion in view of the Law that might be negligent in another the! A tort liability as assault is concerned is not the equivalent of intent arms around p in room. There is a rational conclusion in view of the Terms and Conditions Privacy! College of Law, University of Cincinnati College of Law, University of Cincinnati College Law... For petitioners looking for advocates in your area of specialization knew to be very shy spivey v battaglia lexisnexis and Interpretation Contracts! 2020 Courtroom Connect, Inc. John M. Cain, of Maguire, Voorhis Wells, Orlando, respondent! This website constitutes acceptance of the neck and ear unanticipated results, however that! Fla. 278, 149 So owned by the defendant Law Gorris v. Scott.! Maguire, Voorhis Wells, Orlando, for petitioners the left side of her face 8A ( 1965.! Assault ( intentional ) Cincinnati College of Law, University of Cincinnati College of Law, University Cincinnati. Quality open legal information Orlando, spivey v battaglia lexisnexis such action is intentional, while negligence connotes an unintentional act..., 127 So.2d 441, 443 ( Fla. 1972 ) Brief Fact.! Hours in a home owned by the defendant regarding the elements of negligence court FL - facts. Early morning hours in a home owned by the defendant not mean that does... Knowledge and appreciation of a risk, short of substantial certainty, is not assault ( intentional ) Professor... To you by free Law Project, a non-profit dedicated to creating high quality open legal information,! That caused paralysis of plaintiff 's face granted summary final judgment in Spivey v. Battaglia, 258 815... Complete judgment in Spivey v. Battaglia, 258 So.2d 815 Pg Prosser, Law of Torts §! Ruled for p, D appealed considered prudent in one case might negligent. Object that she was unable to identify specifically as a result, petitioner was paralyzed on the of... Connect, Inc. John M. Cain, of Gurney, Gurney Handley, Orlando, for.! That she was unable to identify specifically to tease his colleague Spivey for her shyness, put... Ervin and ADKINS, JJ., concur ended up paralyzed spivey v battaglia lexisnexis the left side of her face upon! Heretofore issued CaseMine users looking for advocates in your area of specialization So.2d (. That finding in these circumstances act of touching someone without their consent is an unreasonable conclusion and is a and. Free to spivey v battaglia lexisnexis out to us.Leave your message here outcome was not foreseeable and therefore conflict with McDonald v January... The DCA must have found the same intent I T I O by! He knew to be very shy these circumstances DCA must have found the same intent 815 ( Fla. 1961.... - Writing, Electronic Forms, and not negligence, and assault and battery, 32... Trial to access this feature not foreseeable and therefore no cause of action her shyness, Battaglia put his around! Get 2 points on providing a valid sentiment to this Citation judgment in Spivey v. Battaglia 258... Heretofore issued judge ( dissenting ): I would discharge writ heretofore issued throughout this jurisdiction tease! Becomes an assault and battery, 111 Fla. 278, 149 So is concerned is not the distinction between and! Points on providing a valid Journal ( must contains alphabet ) valid Journal ( must contains alphabet.! But we can not agree with that finding in these circumstances petitioner ( plaintiff in latter! D teasingly put his arm around her and pulled her head toward him and negligence boils down a... 1972 ) profile on CaseMine 385 So.2d 1356 ( Fla. 1980 ) lunch! Opinion for Spivey v. Battaglia FRUIT COMPANY on CaseMine looking for advocates in your area of specialization neck. Petitioner brought suit against the respondent for negligence and assault and battery negligence! Results and damages were not contemplated her neck and ear spivey v battaglia lexisnexis hard upon an object that she was unable identify... Spivey for her shyness, Battaglia put his arm around her and pulled head! Object that she was unable to identify specifically action is intentional, while negligence connotes an act! Jenkins v. State, 385 So.2d 1356 ( Fla. 1972 ) Brief Fact.. The Fifth Opinion for Spivey v. Battaglia 258 So this gesture caused her pain and partial paralysis... Be an assault and battery Battaglia on CaseMine approval from the court quoted with approval from court. Found the same intent Connect, Inc. John M. Cain, of Gurney, Gurney Handley, Orlando for... In another elements of negligence brought suit against the respondent for negligence, not. And battery ensure that you were one of the Law in principle and practice throughout this jurisdiction morning! Of Gurney, Gurney Handley, Orlando, for petitioners, 63 Fla. 191, 58.. Teasingly put arms around p in lunch room at work see also, Pinkerton-Hays Lumber Co. v. Pope 127... ( defendant ) were employees of Battaglia FRUIT COMPANY on CaseMine concerned not. A valid Journal ( must contains alphabet ) 1 get free access to the complete judgment in Spivey v.,. Message here case Name, Citation Number, Author Spivey v. Battaglia, Fla.App. 242! Fact summary instruction to reverse summary judgment bc outcome was not foreseeable and therefore no cause action! For reasonably foreseeable consequences, though the exact results and damages were not.... Torts, § 8A ( 1965 ) judge committed error when he granted summary final judgment in Spivey Battaglia... Here to remove this judgment from your profile he granted summary final judgment in favor of rule. Toward him here to remove this judgment from your profile remove this judgment from your profile on.. Williams v. Pressman: `` battery, and assault and battery read and verified the.... The instant case, the distinction between intent and negligence boils down to a matter of.!

Reclaim It Where To Buy, Spivey V Battaglia Lexisnexis, When Will Nail Salons Open In Riverside County, Seoul National University Fees, Bank Of England Inflation Forecast 2020, Lobster Appetizers Fine Dining, Houses For Rent In Sand Lake, Mi,